The Skeptic's Guide to Health Sharing

Health Sharing Sounds Too Good to Be True.Here's the Truth.

You've heard the skepticism. "It's a scam." "They won't pay out." "There's no accountability." Those are fair concerns — and they deserve direct answers, not a sales pitch. That's what this page is.

This website is an independent educational resource operated by Eric Baird, an independent representative of Zion HealthShare (Affiliate Code: 170039). HealthShare programs are not insurance and are not regulated by state insurance departments. Sharing of medical costs is not guaranteed.

✅ BBB Accredited Non-Profit✅ Federal Law Recognition Since 1996✅ 77,000+ Members✅ $91M+ Shared With Members in 2025✅ Published Member Guidelines✅ No Religious Test Required

8 Myths About Health Sharing — Addressed Directly

These are the objections people actually have. We're not softening them. We're answering them.

"Health sharing is basically a scam."

Zion HealthShare is a registered 501(c)(3) non-profit, accredited by the Better Business Bureau, and has been operating since 2019. Health care sharing ministries have been recognized in federal law since 1996 (26 U.S.C. § 5000A(d)(2)(B)). Members receive a published Member Guidelines document — a legally binding contract — before they pay a single dollar. Scams don't publish their rules in advance.

BBB Accredited · 501(c)(3) Non-Profit · Federal law recognition since 1996

"They just deny claims like insurance does."

Zion HealthShare doesn't 'deny claims' — it shares eligible medical expenses according to published guidelines members agree to upfront. Unlike insurance, there's no adjuster looking for loopholes. The IUA (Initial Unshared Amount) is your responsibility — everything above it that meets the guidelines goes to the sharing community. Members can see the sharing history and track their submissions through the member portal.

Sharing decisions governed by published Member Guidelines — not internal underwriting

"You need to be religious to join."

Zion HealthShare does not require members to hold any specific religious belief. The community is faith-motivated but membership is open to anyone who agrees to the community's values and guidelines. You are not required to attend church, sign a statement of faith, or belong to any denomination.

No religious test for membership — open to all who share the community values

"It won't pay out for anything serious."

Major medical events — surgeries, hospitalizations, cancer treatment, emergency care — are exactly what Zion HealthShare is designed for. Once you meet your IUA (which functions like a deductible), eligible major expenses are submitted to the sharing community. Members have shared expenses for open-heart surgery, cancer treatment, and six-figure hospital bills. The key word is 'eligible' — read the Member Guidelines before enrolling.

Major medical events including surgery, hospitalization, and cancer treatment are eligible for sharing

"Pre-existing conditions are never shared."

This is the most nuanced myth. Member health status does not determine whether someone may join, while expenses tied to pre-membership medical conditions follow a published sharing schedule. The amount available is $0 in year one, up to $25,000 in year two, up to $50,000 in year three, and up to $125,000 in each membership year after reaching year four. For people with significant ongoing conditions, the current Member Guidelines matter — and they should be reviewed before enrolling.

Published pre-membership phase-in: $0 → $25,000 → $50,000 → $125,000 per membership year

"There's no accountability if something goes wrong."

Zion HealthShare publishes its Member Guidelines publicly, maintains BBB accreditation, and operates as a non-profit with IRS oversight. Members who have disputes can escalate through a formal review process outlined in the guidelines. Unlike an insurance company, Zion HealthShare is a community — members have a direct stake in how it operates. The organization's financials are subject to non-profit reporting requirements.

Non-profit IRS oversight · BBB accreditation · Published dispute resolution process

"The savings aren't real — there are hidden fees."

The monthly contribution is the primary cost. There is also an IUA (Initial Unshared Amount) — Zion HealthShare offers $1,250, $2,500, and $5,000 IUA options per incident. There are no co-pays, no annual deductible accumulation across incidents, and no network penalty fees. A family of four can typically participate for $400–$700/month depending on age and IUA selection — compared to $1,200–$2,000/month for comparable ACA plans.

Typical family savings: $500–$1,200/month vs. ACA marketplace plans

"Health sharing is just for people who can't afford real insurance."

The fastest-growing segment of Zion HealthShare members are self-employed professionals, small business owners, and dual-income families who can afford ACA insurance — and choose not to pay for it. When a healthy 42-year-old can participate for $280/month instead of paying $680/month for a high-deductible ACA plan they rarely use, the math is straightforward. This isn't a last resort. For the right profile, it's the better financial decision.

Fastest-growing member segment: self-employed professionals and small business owners

See Zion HealthShare for Yourself →

HealthShare memberships are not health insurance. Read the Member Guidelines before enrolling.

Need a deeper answer?

Read the Source-Backed Skeptic Guides

Review one hard question at a time—from financial disclosures to pre-membership conditions—with direct links to the current written sources.

Browse skeptic answers →

A quick visual overview

Prefer a 90-Second Explanation?

Watch this straightforward introduction to Zion HealthShare, then come back to the myths and facts below to evaluate the details for yourself.

Prefer YouTube? Watch the video there →

What Zion HealthShare Actually Does

Not vague reassurance. Specific, verifiable facts about how the organization operates.

Published Member Guidelines

Every sharing decision Zion HealthShare makes is governed by the Member Guidelines — a detailed document members receive before enrolling. There is no hidden underwriting criteria. If an expense is not eligible for sharing, the guidelines say why.

The IUA Structure (How It Works)

The Initial Unshared Amount (IUA) is your per-incident responsibility — similar to a deductible but it resets per incident, not annually. Zion HealthShare offers $1,250, $2,500, and $5,000 IUA options. Monthly contribution rates may vary slightly for tobacco or cannabis users, as disclosed during enrollment. For added peace of mind, a household is responsible for no more than three IUAs in any rolling 12-month period; after the third verified IUA, additional eligible sharing requests over $500 have no further IUA responsibility. For maternity, the $1,250 and $2,500 tiers use a standard $2,500 maternity IUA, while the $5,000 tier remains $5,000.

Non-Profit Accountability

Zion HealthShare is a registered 501(c)(3) non-profit subject to IRS reporting requirements. Its financials are not hidden. It maintains BBB accreditation, which requires a commitment to resolve consumer complaints and maintain transparent business practices.

Sharing History

Zion HealthShare publishes data on its sharing history. Members can verify that expenses are actually being shared — not just promised. This transparency is one of the key differences between a legitimate sharing community and a fraudulent one.

Member Reviews You Can Read

Zion HealthShare has hundreds of verifiable member reviews on Google, BBB, and Trustpilot. Read them — including the negative ones. The negative reviews are informative: most complaints relate to pre-existing condition phase-in rules or expenses that weren't eligible per the guidelines members agreed to.

Federal Legal Recognition

Health care sharing ministries are explicitly recognized in the Affordable Care Act (26 U.S.C. § 5000A(d)(2)(B)). This isn't a legal gray area. Congress specifically carved out an exemption for sharing ministry members from the individual mandate — acknowledging these organizations as a legitimate alternative to insurance.

Ready to See the Actual Numbers?

Visit Zion HealthShare directly and get real pricing for your family size and age. No email required to see rates.

See Zion HealthShare Rates →

HealthShare memberships are not health insurance.

Frequently Asked Questions

Direct answers first. Details after.

Yes. Zion HealthShare is a BBB-accredited, IRS-recognized 501(c)(3) non-profit health care sharing ministry operating under federal law. It publishes its Member Guidelines publicly and has a documented sharing history.

Health care sharing ministries are explicitly recognized in the Affordable Care Act (26 U.S.C. § 5000A(d)(2)(B)), which exempts members from the individual mandate. Zion HealthShare was founded in 2019, is headquartered in St. George, Utah, and maintains Better Business Bureau accreditation. Members receive a copy of the Member Guidelines — a detailed document governing all sharing decisions — before enrolling. The organization is subject to IRS non-profit reporting requirements.

Zion HealthShare facilitates sharing of eligible medical expenses above your chosen IUA (Initial Unshared Amount), including doctor visits, urgent care, surgery, hospitalization, specialist care, lab work, and major medical events. Pre-membership medical conditions follow a published annual phase-in schedule rather than a blanket four-year exclusion.

The IUA functions similarly to a deductible but applies per incident rather than accumulating annually. Once your IUA is met for a given medical incident, you submit the eligible expenses through the member portal and the community shares the remainder. The three IUA options are $1,250, $2,500, and $5,000. Expenses tied to pre-membership medical conditions may be eligible for sharing up to $0 in year one, $25,000 in year two, $50,000 in year three, and $125,000 in each membership year after year four, subject to the current Member Guidelines.

Yes. If you have health insurance, a group plan, government assistance, or similar benefits, those sources handle eligible medical expenses first. Zion HealthShare may then facilitate sharing of remaining eligible expenses after those options are exhausted, subject to the current Member Guidelines.

This is standard coordination: disclose any other available benefits when you submit a sharing request, including insurance, workers’ compensation, liability coverage, government assistance, or a similar arrangement. The goal is a clear order of responsibility, not duplicate payment. If you have a specific situation, ask which current guideline section applies before a medical need arises.

Direct Membership includes Primestin Care resources. Members age 13 and older can use TalkspaceGo, a self-guided wellness app with reflection prompts, classes, and workshops; it is not licensed therapy. Members may also choose discounted access to a licensed Talkspace therapist for $50 per month for the first three months, then $200 per month if continued.

Mental-health treatment costs and treatment related to neurodivergent conditions, including ADHD or autism, are not eligible for community sharing under the current Member Guidelines. The Primestin Care resources and discounted licensed-therapy option are separate membership benefits, not community sharing. If this is important to your family, contact Eric to talk through whether Direct Membership is an appropriate fit.

Yes. Zion HealthShare states that it facilitates sharing of eligible medical expenses for cancer diagnosis and treatment, subject to the current Member Guidelines and the facts of the individual sharing request.

Cancer is a serious concern, so it is worth reviewing the current guidelines rather than relying on a broad marketing statement. Before enrolling, ask about the applicable documentation, IUA, active-membership requirements, and any pre-membership medical-condition rules that may apply to your individual history.

If an expense is not shared, Zion HealthShare will provide a written explanation citing the specific guideline that applies. Members can request a formal review through the dispute resolution process outlined in the Member Guidelines.

Unlike an insurance denial, which can be opaque and driven by internal underwriting criteria, Zion HealthShare's sharing decisions are governed by the published Member Guidelines that members agreed to upfront. If you believe a sharing decision was made in error, the guidelines outline a step-by-step appeal process. The BBB accreditation also provides an independent channel for unresolved complaints.

No. Zion HealthShare is a faith-motivated community but does not require members to hold any specific religious belief, attend church, or sign a statement of faith. Membership is open to anyone who agrees to the community guidelines.

Some health care sharing ministries do require a statement of faith or proof of church membership. Zion HealthShare does not. The community is rooted in shared values around health stewardship and community responsibility, but these are not enforced through religious tests. Members from all backgrounds — including those with no religious affiliation — participate.

Zion HealthShare is not insurance. It is a community where members voluntarily share each other's eligible medical expenses. There are no networks, no referrals, no annual deductible accumulation, and no government mandate to purchase it.

The key structural differences: (1) You present as a self-pay patient and submit expenses after the fact, rather than using an insurance card at the point of service. (2) There is no network — you can see any licensed provider. (3) Sharing decisions are governed by published community guidelines, not internal underwriting. (4) The IUA applies per incident, not annually. (5) It is not regulated as insurance and does not carry state insurance guaranty fund protections. For healthy individuals and families who understand these differences, it often provides better value than comparable insurance plans.

Still Have Questions?

Enter your info and Eric — an independent Zion HealthShare affiliate — will send you a straight answer to whatever's holding you back.

🔒 Your information is 100% secure and will never be shared.

Your information is never sold or shared with third parties.

Prefer to talk? Call Eric at 435-375-4377 or email eric@whatishealthshare.com for a straightforward answer.

⚠️ Important Disclosure

HealthShare memberships are NOT insurance. Zion HealthShare is a non-profit medical cost-sharing community, not an insurance company. Members voluntarily share each other's eligible medical expenses. Membership does not guarantee payment of any medical expense. HealthShare programs are exempt from the Affordable Care Act (ACA) and do not meet the minimum essential coverage requirements. Please review the Member Guidelines carefully before joining.

Affiliate Disclosure: This website contains affiliate links. If you click through and become a Zion HealthShare member, we may receive a commission at no additional cost to you. We only recommend programs we genuinely believe in and that align with our mission to help families find better healthcare alternatives.

Residents of Maryland, Massachusetts, Pennsylvania, Montana, and Washington are not eligible for the Zion HealthShare affiliate program.

© 2026 TryHealthShare.com.
This site is not affiliated with Facebook, Inc. FACEBOOK is a trademark of Meta Platforms, Inc.